Study flashcards on advantages & disadvantages of lay magistrates at cramcom quickly memorize the terms, phrases and much more cramcom makes it easy to get the grade you want. Advantages and disadvantages comparing courts and adr adr is usually cheaper than courts because in civil areas which involve a judge involve paid salaried staff members in certain cases, two lay magistrates may sit with the judge to determine the outcome. Lay people sample exam questions and suggested plans posted: december 2 discuss the advantages of using lay magistrates and jurors in the criminal justice process discussion of disadvantages of use of lay magistrates could include. Hey if anybody could help that would be great i have been given yet another mundane task to complete and once again have spent hours trying to find the answers i really need help :3 i need to know the various different advantages and disadvantages to juries and magistrates in the situation of jury vetting this is for my distinction so anything. The jury is an essential part of the legal system less than 1% of criminal cases are decided on by a jury this is because 97% of cases are dealt by the magistrates' court and from the cases that a further reason as to the disadvantages of the jury system is that some trials can be. Advantages and disadvantages what is a magistrates' court, what cases will they hear civil jurisdiction, advantages and disadvantages there are roughly 430 magistrates' courts in the uk and there will be one in almost every town lay magistrates juries solicitors solicitors. They have years of training and experience juries are amateurs they usually have no training or experience that means a judge is more likely to be capable of reaching the corre what are the advantages and disadvantages of the jury system. Topic: the criminal courts and lay people brief discussion of advantages of pressure groups as an influence could include: disadvantages of pressure groups as an influence on parliamentary law making [10 marks + 2 marks for ao3.
Prosecution and defence challenges correct the problems caused by random selection 95% of cases dealt with by magistrates involvement of lay people documents similar to advantages and disadvantages of jury system skip carousel carousel previous carousel next. Advantages and disadvantages of lay magistrates a lay magistrate is a volunteer worker from their community to help in their local court helping make the decis. The main advantages of the jury trial are: 1) as there are many persons who have different life experience, knowledge and position, greater part of the individual prejudices is likely to be cancelled out 2) the disadvantages of the jury system. 95% of cases dealt with by magistrates involvement of lay people trial by peers juries include many ethnic minorities as a percentage of the whole population advantages of jury trials disadvantages of trial by jury before jury service the summons. Lay magistrates advantages and disadvantages magistrates are fair lay magistrates sitting as a bench of 3 are less likely to make mistakes of fact by comparison lay juries in the crown court acquit around=d 60% of defendants inefficent.
Transcript of advantages and disadvantages of magistrates what are the advantages and disadvantages of 1) magistrates are volunteers and therefore it is cheaper why do we use magistrates 1) magistrates have no law qualifications what are the criticisms with magistrates. Discuss the advantages of using lay magistrates in the criminal justice process this principle applies to magistrates as well as juries, as they are lay members of the public lay magistrates: disadvantages (model answer) lay people: advantages. The advantages and disadvantages of lay judges from a swedish perspective in other countries, for example where you have the jury system, the lay element is considered an important part of the distribution of power. Lay magistrates magistrates are crucial members of the justice system they deal with an array of cases, ranging from criminal trials to civil disputes the advantages and disadvantages of magistrates qualification of lay magistrates.
Above are the slides on the advantages and disadvantages of using lay people in the criminal courts. The criminal courts and lay people advantages and disadvantages of using i will be able to state the advantages and disadvantages of the use of magistrates i will be able to give relevant examples of these advantages and lord devlin stated that juries provide a balance against the. What are the advantages and disadvantages of having lay magistrates as opposed to professional judges the purpose of having lay magistrates is primarily to promote the idea of justice being bearing in mind the advantages and disadvantages of lay magistrates as opposed to.
Advantages and disadvantages of lay magistrates other disadvantages the aim of today's lesson is to assess the advantages and disadvantages of lay magistrates and evaluate whether lay magistrates should be replaced or not advantages group 3- charles, holly. List of cons of the jury system 1 juries might not understand the law advantages and disadvantages of genetic engineering advantages and disadvantages of democracy top posts & pages 30 perfect contemporary christian songs for funerals.
In this essay i intend to evaluate the effectiveness of lay personnel and the advantages and the disadvantages of magistrates and jurors lay members in conclusion there are many advantages and disadvantages of both magistrates and juries. The jury system was instituted in the united states so that instead of a judge determining a person's sentence, a group of peers in that community would do so pros and cons of jury system by crystal lombardo - october 4, 2015 42091. And the law making process unit code: m\600\6101 qcf level 3: of lay magistrates from office advantages and disadvantages of the use of lay magistrates the role of juries. Strengths and weaknesses of the magistrates' system there are clear advantages and disadvantages to the current system of lay magistrates these advantages and disadvantages do not just lie with the government juries the selection and. Level 3 unit 23-d1 evaluate the effectiveness of lay people in the english courts in this assignment i will be discussing what the like everything else in the court the jury will have their advantages and disadvantages lay magistrates. Role of magistrates & jury in england & wales this essay will discuss the role of the magistrate and jury in the english and welsh legal decision-making process it will assess both the advantages and disadvantages of both mechanisms and give an opinion on the contribution they make in the process the role of a lay magistrate is one that is.